We might earn income from the merchandise out there on this web page and take part in affiliate applications. Be taught Extra ›
Among the many most iconic American firearms, the Colt 1911 Authorities mannequin designed by John Browning is on the high of the record. Others embody Colt’s Single-Motion Military, the Winchester Mannequin 1873, and maybe the Winchester Mannequin 70—however nobody would argue whether or not the 1911 deserves a spot on the rostrum.
The attraction of the 1911 isn’t fading anytime quickly. Regardless of the dominance of striker-fired polymer-framed pistols within the defensive handgun market, gross sales of 1911s stay sturdy. Furthermore, gun makers proceed to develop into the 1911 world, as Savage has this yr, or develop the quantity and varieties of 1911s they make.
![](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/2GqyG3jCWZs/hqdefault.jpg)
We simply completed our annual assessments of new rifles and new handguns at Gunsite Academy in Arizona. Gunsite, as you would possibly know, is a Mecca for the 1911 and people who like to shoot them. It was based by Jeff Cooper who was a diehard advocate of the single-stack .45 ACP as a defensive combating instrument.
I and my fellow Outside Life gunslingers figured what higher place to check the sector of finest 1911s than this hallowed floor. In order that’s what we did. Together with workers author Tyler Freel and OL contributor Sean Murphy, we put 9 totally different 1911s via our take a look at protocol.
Greatest 1911 Authorities Fashions of 2023
![The guns in the outdoor life best 1911 test](https://www.outdoorlife.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/09/best-1911-group-1-scaled.jpeg?strip=all&quality=85)
To place a fence across the 1911 class, we saved the sector intentionally slender. We solely examined Authorities-sized 1911s, that means full framed pistols with 5-inch barrels. In line with the OG vibe, we additionally restricted it to single-stack 8-round .45s. Likewise, we eschewed pistols with accent rails apart from the Springfield Emissary.
This allow us to deal with conventional 1911s and conduct an apples-to-apples evaluation. As a helpful benchmark we included a Remington Rand 1911 A1 of World Conflict Two classic that’s owned by Sean Murphy, which he acquired years again via the Civilian Marksmanship Program (CMP).
However even throughout the tight confines of this challenge we had fairly a range. The costs ranged from $519 for the Taylor’s & Firm Straight Grip 1911 to the princely $4,700 price ticket on the Nighthawk Customized Hearth Hawk.
With these two pistols bookending the value spectrum, we shortly noticed that—for probably the most half—you get what you pay for. The dearer pistols had higher workmanship, smoother actions, nicer ergonomics and aesthetics, and, generally, higher efficiency and accuracy than their less-costly counterparts.
Why the 1911 Will By no means Die
![](https://www.outdoorlife.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/09/TJD06345-scaled.jpg?strip=all&quality=85)
The 1911 was the standard-issue sidearm of the U.S. navy from 1911 to 1985. No different pistol has had an equal run.
One would assume that the curiosity in a sidearm would wane as soon as it’s put out to pasture, however a part of what makes the 1911 saga so fascinating is how the platform has advanced to remain related.
It was as if the 1911 was a phoenix rising from the ashes, emphasizing designs that put a premium on the 1911’s functionality as a precision taking pictures instrument, slightly than as an on a regular basis working service pistol.
You see that evolution on this subject of pistols. At one finish is the Remington GI mannequin. It’s primary and has a function set that didn’t deviate one iota from the opposite 1911s of the time. This allowed for components to be interchanged simply to maintain the pistols in service.
.embed-container { place: relative; padding-bottom: 30.25%; peak: 0; overflow: hidden; max-width: 100%; } .embed-container iframe, .embed-container object, .embed-container embed { place: absolute; high: 0; left: 0; width: 100%; peak: 100%; }
On the different finish are high-performance 1911s, just like the Nighthawk Customized, Wilson Fight, and Kimber, that share a primary design however incorporate distinctive components and options that now not enable for the straightforward alternate of components that outlined the sooner generations.
In current a long time demand for 1911s has solely elevated and gun corporations responded with quite a lot of manufacturing facility, {custom}, and semi-custom choices. After greater than 110 years, the timeless 1911 continues to be going sturdy.
How We Take a look at
Usually once we conduct our assessments, we collect as many new weapons within the class as we are able to and have our panel of judges shoot and grade them. What’s totally different about this 1911 roundup is that we didn’t restrict it to new weapons however included some fashions which were produced for years.
![Tester shoots one of the best 1911s](https://www.outdoorlife.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/09/TJD05960-scaled.jpg?strip=all&quality=85)
Aside from that small twist, the take a look at protocol is similar. We shot the handguns for accuracy at 15 yards off tripods with sandbag helps. To reach on the accuracy figures we used the identical varieties of ammo in every gun and took the common of the ten finest five-shot teams.
As soon as that was full, we switched to sensible taking pictures drills. We shot El Presidente, X drills, and Invoice drills. We ran the pistols on spinners, plate racks, poppers, and different metal targets. All advised, we put a number of hundred rounds via every pistol—although some group favorites had spherical counts approaching 1,000.
We made all that brass fly to get a really feel for the workmanship, dealing with, reliability, and different qualities that we grade the weapons on. After analyzing the scores, we found out which pistols deserved awards for numerous classes.
How We Grade
Every handgun is evaluated on 9 standards and given a rating of 1 to five from every decide, apart from the accuracy rating, which relies on the info from the teams shot. We common the scores for every standards and use that to find out the rating and awards. The classes are dealing with, accuracy, workmanship, aesthetics, ergonomics, meets goal, versatility, reliability, and worth.
The scores then translate to the grades on the report playing cards for every firearm. Efficiency consists of the scores from dealing with, accuracy, ergonomics, and reliability. Design contains workmanship, aesthetics, assembly its goal, and flexibility. Worth stands by itself.
To earn an “Glorious” ranking, the common of that rating should be 4.5 or greater, a tough mark to hit. “Very Good” is a median rating of three.5 to 4.5; “Good” is from 2.5 to three.5; “Truthful” is from 1.5 to 2.5; and “Poor” is beneath 1.5.
Professionals
- Premium high quality elements and match
- Very correct
- Very clean taking pictures
- Glorious ergonomics
Report Card
- Efficiency: Glorious
- Design: Glorious
- Worth: Good
- Accuracy: 1.33 in. (Common of 10 finest five-shot teams at 15 yards)
Nighthawk Customized Hearth Hawk Specs
- Motion: Single-action semi-auto
- Caliber: .45 ACP
- Capability: 8+1
- Weight: 2 lb. 9 oz.
- Set off: 4 lb. 10 oz.
- Barrel: 4.5 in.
- Size: 8.25 in.
- Worth: $6,631
Shooters who’re into handguns have seemingly heard of Nighthawk Customized. And if there’s just one factor they know concerning the firm’s pistols it’s that they’re costly. The million-dollar query—or with the Hearth Hawk, the $6,600 query—is: are they price it?
We had been skeptical at first. That’s an terrible lot of cheddar.
![Loading a magazine into the Nighthawk Fire Hawk](https://www.outdoorlife.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/09/TJD06276-scaled.jpg?strip=all&quality=85)
However then we shot it. And shot it some extra. And a few extra after that. In reality, I had a tough time conserving my fellow shooters’ grubby mitts off the Hearth Hawk as soon as the take a look at bought rolling.
The pistol is superlative. The motion is tight and clean and ran completely throughout our week of set off pulling. The Hearth Hawk is correct—it turned in one of many subject’s finest total accuracy scores—and, due to its efficient compensator, shoots very flat.
The Hearth Hawk simply dealt with each process we threw at it. El Prez, OL’s charging bear drill, flipping spinners—it didn’t matter. The Nighthawk crushed all of them.
It earned “wonderful” scores throughout the board, apart from its versatility (superb) and worth (good)—and was the best total scoring pistol of the take a look at.
“The set off is a dream.” “It needs to go quick.” “Greatest-in-class ergonomics.” “Extraordinarily refined.” These had been among the observations my fellow testers jotted down on their analysis sheets. No surprise I couldn’t pry the pistol from their palms.
Aesthetically the Hearth Hawk is blessed with attractive, purposeful appears to be like. The aggressive scallops reduce into the grips are cool as hell but additionally surprisingly snug and provides the shooter fabulous management over the .45.
![The gold sight on the Nighthawk Fire Hawk](https://www.outdoorlife.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/09/TJD06291-scaled.jpg?strip=all&quality=85)
The Hearth Hawk comes with a 14-karat gold bead entrance sight that grew on us over the take a look at. It feels prefer it could possibly be a gimmick, but it surely was fairly efficient paired with a Heinie Black Slant Professional rear.
Although we shot it solely utilizing irons (as we did with all of the 1911s), the Hearth Hawk has an optics reduce within the slide, which is a pleasant function that takes slightly sting out of the value.
There’s little question that the Hearth Hawk isn’t for everybody. However there’s additionally little question in our minds that the associated fee is justified primarily based on what it delivers. It is without doubt one of the most interesting 1911s you should buy.
Professionals
- Glorious high quality
- Nice grip and management ergonomics
- Correct
- Clean-shooting
Report Card
- Efficiency: Glorious
- Design: Very Good
- Worth: Very Good
- Accuracy: 1.193 in. (Common of 10 finest five-shot teams at 15 yards)
Wilson Fight ACP Specs
- Motion: Single-action semi-auto
- Caliber: .45 ACP
- Capability: 8+1
- Weight: 2 lb. 8 oz.
- Set off: 3 lb. 13 oz.
- Barrel: 5 in.
- Size: 8.5 in.
- Worth: $3,033
![Shooting the best 1911](https://www.outdoorlife.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/09/TJD06653-scaled.jpg?strip=all&quality=85)
Wilson Fight is without doubt one of the most extremely revered names within the 1911 recreation. Invoice Wilson frolicked his shingle in 1977 and over the a long time has turned the corporate bearing his identify into one of many largest {custom} and semi-custom firearms makers within the nation.
The ACP is one among Wilson’s newer fashions. To maintain the prices down, Wilson restricted the menu of choices on the ACP, which explains its standing as a semi-custom providing. As with the opposite 1911s in take a look at, we went with a full-sized Authorities mannequin in .45 ACP, although it may be had in Commander (4.25-inch barrel) and Compact (4-inch barrel) trim, and in 9mm as effectively.
The ACP was probably the most correct 1911 we examined, printing five-shot teams averaging 1.193 inches at 15 yards. The set off on it’s wonderful and the sights are top-notch.
![loading magazine for the best 1911 test](https://www.outdoorlife.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/09/TJD06949-scaled.jpg?strip=all&quality=85)
Wilson refers back to the slide’s cocking serrations and the cuts machined into the grips as its “Eagle Claw sample.” This design is new from the corporate and lives as much as its billing by providing a stable, snug grip that isn’t susceptible to snagging on holsters or clothes.
The all-black end on the ACP contrasts with the polished stainless barrel and the uncovered crimson fiber-optic entrance sight. When it comes to appears to be like and efficiency, this pistol is all enterprise.
The ACP digested all varieties of ammo with none hitches and executed all our drills with pace and assurance.
The one aesthetic critique we had is that for the value the engraving on the slide could possibly be nicer. It appears to be laser reduce slightly than machined. Entrance cocking serrations can be a helpful function to have as effectively, however that can be a matter of non-public desire.
These are small gripes for what’s in actuality a top-notch working gun. When you’re going to hold a 1911 to save lots of your bacon, you can do lots worse than having a Wilson Fight ACP in your hip.
Professionals
- Nice high quality
- Hand-tuned
- Correct
- Personalised Gunsite contact
Report Card
- Efficiency: Very Good
- Design: Very Good
- Worth: Very Good
- Accuracy: 1.69 in. (Common of 10 finest five-shot teams at 15 yards)
Gunsite GSP Specs
- Motion: Single-action semi-auto
- Caliber: .45 ACP
- Capability: 8+1
- Weight: 2 lb. 5 oz.
- Set off: 3 lb. 12 oz.
- Barrel: 5 in.
- Size: 8.5 in.
- Worth: $1,625
![](https://www.outdoorlife.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/09/TJD07080-scaled.jpg?strip=all&quality=85)
It seems that Gunsite had slightly shock ready for the Outside Life gun take a look at group this yr. After we bought settled in, they advised us about this new handgun and requested if we needed to be the primary to shoot and take a look at it. There isn’t a timeline within the multiverse the place we’d flip down that provide, so after getting the walkthrough of the construct I took it proper all the way down to the vary to place some rounds via it.
I used to be slightly nervous for the Gunsite Gunsmithy, a store of proficient gunsmiths beneath the course of Dave Fink. (They’re the crew liable for constructing the GSP, which they do by hand.) They’d solely finalized the design a couple of days prior, and this was the primary prototype.
I needn’t have fearful. The Gunsite GSP ran extraordinarily effectively and impressed all of us. For the value it’s a hell of a pistol—and one which Jeff Cooper would have accredited of.
There’s nothing extraneous on the GSP. It’s a simple combating gun that embodies the Gunsite coaching philosophy and ethos. The controls on the pistol are clean, however tactile, and effectively laid out. They provide the operator constructive suggestions and are intuitive to make use of.
The scales on the grip and engraving on the metallic are engaging and effectively executed. And the signature Gunsite raven silhouette reduce into the hammer is a cool contact. The pistol isn’t flashy, however particulars like this elevate it above the gang.
The components used within the pistol are prime quality, and the match and end of the construct is excellent as effectively.
![](https://www.outdoorlife.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/09/TJD07046-scaled.jpg?strip=all&quality=85)
Lots of expert handwork goes into the GSPs. The Gunsmithy does all of the end work on the pistols. They match the barrels, execute all of the stampings, reduce the cocking serrations, bevel the magazine effectively, repair and regulate the sights, and do all of the dehorning.
Our pattern was a bit choosy operating JHPs, a typical concern with 1911s, however because it was a prototype, I’ve each confidence that Fink and his crew will overcome that hiccup.
By the tip of the take a look at we had been pretty smitten with the GSP. It’s the first Gunsite branded pistol to be constructed on their campus in 20 years and is a deal at its asking value. We preferred it a lot, actually, that three of us ordered GSPs on the spot, which is as sturdy an endorsement of a handgun as you’ll discover.
Professionals
- Inexpensive
- True-to-form parkerized end
- Capabilities effectively
- Nice worth
Cons
- Not very refined
- Has some sharp edges
Report Card
- Efficiency: Good
- Design: Good
- Worth: Glorious
- Accuracy: 2.017 in. (Common of 10 finest five-shot teams at 15 yards)
Taylor’s & Co. 1911 A1 Straight Grip Specs
- Motion: Single-action semi-auto
- Caliber: .45 ACP
- Capability: 8+1
- Weight: 2 lb. 6 oz.
- Set off: 6 lb. 12 oz.
- Barrel: 5 in.
- Size: 8.5 in.
- Worth: $449
When you like 1911s, you’d have a tough time resisting the charms of this GI mannequin import. We actually couldn’t. This candy little gun doesn’t value a lot and presents lots for the cash—particularly when you’re thinking about proudly owning a trustworthy M1911 A1 service pistol duplicate. These 1911s are constructed within the Philippines and seem like one thing granddad would have carried within the Massive One.
![](https://www.outdoorlife.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/09/TJD07206-scaled.jpg?strip=all&quality=85)
They arrive with gentle coloured wooden shares with primary diamond checkering. The magwell is reduce as straight as a Marine at consideration. The hammer has a thumb spur with a little bit of checkering on the tip. The mounted sights are puny. And the thumb security is small by most of right this moment’s requirements and a bit stiff to function.
Nonetheless, we had loads of enjoyable taking pictures this pistol and are completely happy to report that it ran very effectively—with ball ammo at any fee. Hole factors gave it indigestion, in order that value it some within the reliability class. This didn’t shock us, nevertheless, since 1911s that haven’t been labored over are likely to have points with JHPs.
The accuracy on our pattern was first rate. With five-shot teams averaging simply over two inches it held its personal within the subject.
![Inspecting targets shot by the best 1911](https://www.outdoorlife.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/09/DSC08380-1-scaled.jpg?strip=all&quality=85)
Recoil on it was noticeably snappier than with the extra refined pistols within the take a look at. The form of the beavertail is slender on the tip inflicting the pistol to chew the online of the hand. It didn’t shoot as flat as others within the take a look at, nor was it as quick due to the undersized sights.
That mentioned, we are able to extremely advocate this pistol for shooters on a price range who need a good starter-level GI 1911—both to maintain in inventory trim or to improve over time. For the value, it may possibly’t be beat.
Professionals
- Correct
- Capabilities effectively
- Excessive-traction grip texture
Report Card
- Efficiency: Very Good
- Design: Good
- Worth: Good
- Accuracy: 1.514 in. (Common of 10 finest five-shot teams at 15 yards)
Kimber Rapide Scorpius Specs
- Motion: Single-action semi-auto
- Caliber: .45 ACP
- Capability: 8+1
- Weight: 2 lb. 8 oz.
- Set off: 4 lb. 13 oz.
- Barrel: 5 in.
- Size: 8.5 in.
- Worth: $1,424
The Kimber Rapide Scorpius doesn’t do refined. It’s a pistol designed to draw consideration. And may the opposite shooters at your gun membership in some way fail to take be aware, you’ll be able to merely catch the solar’s reflection on its mirror-bright polished flats on the slide and blind them.
![The Kimber Rapide one of the best 1911 handguns](https://www.outdoorlife.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/09/TJD06329-scaled.jpg?strip=all&quality=85)
The stainless slide has ports reduce into the perimeters and high and deep cocking serrations up entrance and on the rear. To intensify the visible affect, the cuts and recesses are completed in a lovely matte black coating. This similar contrasting aesthetic is labored into the body and grip as effectively. Whereas the Rapide Scorpius makes a daring aesthetic assertion, it serves up a very good portion of steak with all that sizzle. Beneath the bling, it has loads of tremendous qualities that make it a stable shooter. We preferred the grip texture, the scalloped slide cease, flared magwell, and clear set off break.
The ambidextrous security has wonderful proportions—it’s neither too massive nor too small—and we discovered it easy to govern.
The sights are efficient, consisting of a dot inset in a pointy entrance put up and a set rear with a U-notch and small dots to both facet. The three dots glow inexperienced in the dead of night.
The pistol’s accuracy was superb; it was one of many tighter shooters within the take a look at.
Total, we had nothing however excessive reward for the pistol’s ergonomics, dealing with, and workmanship. It additionally earned excessive marks for reliability—we didn’t file a single failure to feed.
Given its flashy appears to be like, it isn’t the only option for hid carry. However for a high-quality gun to brag about whereas taking pictures together with your buddies it’s excellent.
Professionals
- Very correct
- Clean and dependable operate
- Nice dealing with traits
Cons
- Sharp edges didn’t assist ergonomics
Report Card
- Efficiency: Very Good
- Design: Good
- Worth: Very Good
- Accuracy: 1.306 in. (Common of 10 finest five-shot teams at 15 yards)
Springfield 1911 Emissary Specs
- Motion: Single-action semi-auto
- Caliber: .45 ACP
- Capability: 8+1
- Weight: 2 lb. 10 oz.
- Set off: 5 lb. 9 oz.
- Barrel: 5 in.
- Size: 8.5 in.
- Worth: $1,378
The judges on our take a look at group had combined impressions of the Springfield 1911 Emissary. From the standpoint of accuracy and reliability it was a winner. And all of us appreciated how effectively it dealt with throughout our taking pictures drills.
Its aesthetics, nevertheless, struck us as center of the street. Whereas the sharp checkering sample on the grip is visually arresting, as is the squared off set off guard, the pistol has a little bit of a brutish look about it that the two-tone end (a therapy that always imparts a bit of sophistication to a gun) wasn’t capable of dispel. “Industrial” is the phrase one of many judges used. It’s sure to attraction to some shooters, but it surely didn’t win our hearts.
The checkering was a contact too sharp for us as effectively. It supplied nice management of the gun—serving to it earn the excessive scores for dealing with—however value it with respect to its ergonomics. None of us discovered it snug after placing loads of rounds via it.
![Shooting the best 1911 of 2023](https://www.outdoorlife.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/09/Gun-Test-4-scaled.jpeg?strip=all&quality=85)
However the Emissary actually shone in accuracy testing. It was among the many most correct weapons of the take a look at—each within the subject of 1911s and with respect to all the opposite handguns we shot. It was actually probably the most correct for the value.
The sights on the Emissary are daring and constructed for fast work at shut quarters. The entrance sight has a big, shiny dot rimmed in white with a night-sight insert contained inside it. The mounted rear sight has a big U-shaped notch outlined in white as effectively.
The set off on it’s fairly good too. It has constructive take-up, a agency again wall, and a crisp break.
Regardless of our lack of enthusiasm for its appears to be like and ergonomics, we nonetheless contemplate it an excellent worth.
Professionals
- Real standard-issue 1911
- features effectively with ball ammo
- Nostalgic piece of historical past
Cons
- Doesn’t run reliably with some hole level ammunition
- Robust to search out
Report Card
- Efficiency: Good
- Design: Very Good
- Worth: Good
- Accuracy: 2.639 in. (Common of 10 finest five-shot teams at 15 yards)
Remington Rand 1911 A1 GI Mannequin Specs
- Motion: Single-action semi-auto
- Caliber: .45 ACP
- Capability: 8+1
- Weight: 2 lb. 7 oz.
- Set off: 5 lb. 4 oz.
- Barrel: 5 in.
- Size: 8 in.
- Worth: n/a
Lots of the weapons on this roundup are cool, however solely this Remington Rand 1911 A1 is James Dean cool. This can be a Forties classic 1911 bought via the Civilian Marksmanship Program (CMP) by take a look at group member Sean Murphy.
![](https://www.outdoorlife.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/09/TJD07108-scaled.jpg?strip=all&quality=85)
Like many service pistols of the World Conflict Two period, it’s a mutt, combining a Remington slide and barrel and an Ithaca body. This was a typical apply, and the mix-and-match modularity of the platform was one of many 1911’s virtues as a service pistol.
This particular pistol functioned as God and John Browning meant—digesting 230-grain ball ammo as simply because it did within the Pacific and European theaters. It even ran effectively with hole level ammo, particularly once we used greater high quality magazines from Wilson Fight.
The match and end of the pistol are in step with others of the identical origin and classic—and it’s extra correct than many shooters would possibly give it credit score for.
There’s additionally one thing extraordinarily gratifying about pulling the set off on a working piece of historical past—particularly one that may rightfully declare to be a back-to-back World Conflict champ.
Professionals
- Smooth-recoiling
- Good sights
- Correct
Cons
- We skilled some stoppages
- We really feel value is slightly massive excessive for what you’re getting
Report Card
- Efficiency: Good
- Design: Good
- Worth: Truthful
- Accuracy: 1.617 in. (Common of 10 finest five-shot teams at 15 yards)
Savage 1911 Govt Fashion Two Tone Specs
- Motion: Single-action semi-auto
- Caliber: .45 ACP
- Capability: 8+1
- Weight: 2 lb. 8 oz.
- Set off: 4 lb. 9 oz.
- Barrel: 5 in.
- Size: 8.5 in.
- Worth: $1,247
The Savage 1911 Govt Fashion Two Tone is a newcomer to the 1911 world, having simply been launched this yr. The pistol is available in a pair totally different trims—an all-stainless mannequin in addition to in 9mm.
The Govt Fashion is a stable freshman effort. There’s lots we preferred concerning the pistol, beginning with its accuracy. From supported sandbags at 15 yards, it averaged 1.617-inch five-shot teams, which put it within the higher half of efficiency in that class.
To shoot effectively at any vital distance requires good sights, and the Savage comes decked out with a pleasant set of adjustable Novak Lo-Mount sights with a white dot on the entrance put up.
![](https://www.outdoorlife.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/09/Gun-Test-Day-3-56-scaled.jpeg?strip=all&quality=85)
The overall high quality of the construct was fairly good, too. The ambidextrous security was fitted effectively to the body and the slide-to-frame match was tight. Savage did a very good job dehorning the 1911, incorporating good chamfers across the ejection port and the muzzle.
The pistol is fairly mushy taking pictures for a .45; it managed recoil effectively throughout our dynamic taking pictures drills.
However there’s room for enchancment. We had a lot of stoppages with various kinds of ammo, together with ball, that value it within the “reliability” class. The protection is a bit stiff to govern. And the pistol’s aesthetics are common, particularly in gentle of the $1,429 value.
Professionals
- Appears to be like like higher-end 1911s
- Good ergonomics
Cons
- Perform/reliability points
- Not an awesome worth
Report Card
- Efficiency: Truthful
- Design: Good
- Worth: Truthful
- Accuracy: 2.709 in. (Common of 10 finest five-shot teams at 15 yards)
Girsan MC 1911 S Noel Specs
- Motion: Single-action semi-auto
- Caliber: .45 ACP
- Capability: 8+1
- Weight: 2 lb. 11 oz.
- Set off: 5 lb. 11 oz.
- Barrel: 5 in.
- Size: 8.75 in.
- Worth: $1,023
Earlier than the taking pictures began, we had been rooting for the Girsan MC 1911 S Noel to tug a Rocky Balboa and blast its approach to victory as a scrappy, feature-rich, and inexpensive 1911. Alas, this didn’t come to go.
The Girsan began pretty sturdy, however with every passing spherical the damage and tear collected till the Girsan lastly put up its gloves and cried “no mas.” It wasn’t as much as the punishment that our 1911 take a look at dished out.
Girsans are imported from Turkey by EAA Corp, which has constructed a enterprise by providing inexpensive copycat variations of assorted weapons together with Colt’s, Berettas, Browning Hello-Powers, and others.
The MC 1911 S Noel has a powerful spec sheet. It comes with adjustable goal sights. Stainless slide and body. An ambidextrous security. A flared magwell extension. Raised journal launch. Checkering on the back and front straps. Excessive beavertail on the grip. Ahead cocking serrations on the slide.
These are options generally discovered on 1911s carrying a lot greater value tags than the $1,023 that the Girsan lists for.
![](https://www.outdoorlife.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/09/Gun-Test-Day-4-5-145-1-scaled.jpeg?strip=all&quality=85)
Sadly, the entire of the gun is lower than the sum of its components. We noticed a touch of this with the a number of feeding points that persistently plagued the pistol. That sinking feeling was confirmed when the rear sight got here aside after a pair hundred rounds.
A detailed take a look at the pistol exhibits the place the makers reduce corners to maintain the value down. The pistol isn’t dehorned in any respect. The end appears to be like prefer it was utilized by a youngster graffitiing the facet of a derelict constructing. And all of the controls have a gritty, stiff really feel.
The last word drawback is that the Girsan is making an attempt to be one thing it’s not—which is a excessive efficiency 1911.
We’d like to see what they may accomplish with a pistol in step with their talents, alongside the strains of the Taylor’s & Co. 1911. However because it stands, we are able to’t advocate this gun to anybody, particularly a shooter who wants to verify each hard-earned greenback is correctly spent.
Closing Ideas on the Greatest 1911s
![](https://www.outdoorlife.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/09/TJD07067-scaled.jpg?strip=all&quality=85)
That is simply the primary chapter in what will probably be an ongoing challenge to check a broader vary of 1911s. There are a lot of Authorities fashions we plan so as to add to the record. For instance, neither Colt nor Ruger might get us weapons in time, and each belong on this subject.
After which there are all the opposite configurations of 1911s: commander fashions, competitors weapons, compact 1911s, and 1911s chambered in 9mm, .38 Tremendous, and different rounds.
We are going to chip away at these classes as time permits. However the center-of-mass 1911—the basic 5-inch authorities—is effectively represented on this take a look at and was the right place to start out.
FAQ
The 1911 was a revolutionary pistol when it was invented, then it was fight confirmed via a few years of service. It’s nonetheless widespread as a result of it’s correct, dependable, and has an incredible quantity of nostalgia.
Usually, 1911 pistols can malfunction extra simply than many trendy striker-fired pistols, however well-made 1911s are very dependable.
A 1911’s greatest downside is low ammunition capability.
That may be a matter of opinion, however second to the primary one John Browning customary himself, the Nighthawk Customized Firehawk makes a robust case for itself.
About Gunsite
![Gun test team at Gunsite.](https://www.outdoorlife.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/05/TJD01587.jpg?strip=all&quality=85)
This take a look at of one of the best 1911s was graciously hosted by Gunsite Academy in Paulden, Arizona. As the house of the legendary Jeff Cooper and one of many first firearm coaching amenities that provided lessons to most of the people, Gunsite grew to become one of many premier gun coaching locations within the nation.
Cooper can be the Godfather of the fashionable 1911 and its employment as a defensive instrument. The strategies and drills he developed are nonetheless taught by Gunsite’s cadre of wonderful instructors.
Each shooter owes it to themself to take a Gunsite class in some unspecified time in the future—and there’s no higher approach to do this than to join the 250 class with a 1911 in your belt.