Males’s Brooks Cascadia 17 Evaluation

Backside Line

The Brooks Cascadia 17s are versatile, comfy, and breathable footwear constructed for mountaineering lengthy miles on established trails. These footwear are one in all our favorites at CleverHiker: we’ve logged over 6,000 miles on America’s most scenic trails in these footwear, together with the PCT, CDT, the Pinhoti Path, and sections of the Colorado Path. Weighing solely 11 ounces per shoe, they steadiness sturdiness and agility properly because of strong traction and springy foam midsoles that make it a breeze to deal with varied terrains.

Nonetheless, the Cascadias are much less sturdy than different mountaineering footwear, particularly on tough routes, for the reason that skinny higher mesh can develop holes after 400 miles. With a heel-to-toe drop of 8mm, they provide wonderful cushioning, however on the expense of floor really feel. In the event you’re searching for light-weight footwear for a summer time of path runs, day hikes, and long-distance backpacking, these are a fantastic selection.

Consolation

The Brooks Cascadia 17s are comfy out of the field and require virtually no break-in time. Their cosy match and easy, efficient lacing system is a successful mixture that makes these one in all our favorites for lengthy days. The Cascadias really feel safe all day without having to re-tie your laces each few hours. These footwear stand out for his or her wonderful lateral stability, making them really feel agile and strong on most terrain and obstacles.

We’re additionally massive followers of their breathable mesh uppers that maintain your toes cool and dry, which is very noticeable throughout intense exercise and scorching climate. Their versatile uppers permit for pure foot flexion, and the froth midsoles create plush cushioning whether or not you’re working quick downhill on pavement or backpacking slowly uphill. 

The Cascadias have a number of downsides on the subject of consolation, although. This model of the Cascadias has a inflexible inner plastic liner beneath its comfortable ankle cuff that may rub in opposition to ankles over time, resulting in potential ache and irritation on longer outings. And the skinny tongue doesn’t present a lot cushioning, which we actually really feel on the highest of the foot after 15+ mile days. 

The laces, whereas efficient initially, are likely to stiffen over a few hundred miles, and could be a bit cumbersome to string and tie. And, the 8 mm heel-to-toe drop is on the excessive finish on the subject of assist, which could not swimsuit everybody’s biomechanics or wants.

Traction

The Brooks Cascadia 17s have respectable traction because of their sticky rubber outsoles and knobby multidirectional lugs. This tread sample grips surfaces properly throughout ascents because of their triangular tread on the toe and forefoot and supplies dependable braking on the heel on descents, making the Cascadias really feel particularly secure on trails with a number of ups and downs. The Cascadia 17s traction makes them superb for tackling quite a lot of path circumstances for sustaining a gradual tempo and conserving wonderful management.

Though the thick foam midsoles present nice consolation, this quantity of froth reduces your total floor really feel and diminishes the sensory suggestions wanted to regulate your stride and discover good foot placement on technical routes. The lugs on these footwear are additionally a bit shallow, limiting how efficient they’re on slick rocks, steep dust trails, and moist surfaces the place deeper traction issues. We additionally discovered that the tread sturdiness will not be as strong as different path trainers, so it’s possible you’ll need to keep away from rugged terrain otherwise you’ll threat faster put on and have much less efficient grip over time.

Weight

The Brooks Cascadia 17s are a number of the lightest mountaineering footwear we’ve examined, weighing in at only one pound, six ounces for the pair. Due to their mesh woven uppers, skinny TPU overlays, and light-weight foam midsoles, the Cascadias’ low weight will make you are feeling agile all day lengthy and scale back each foot and leg fatigue throughout lengthy days.

The con of such a featherlight shoe is that the Cascadia 17s aren’t very sturdy. Nonetheless, in case your prime precedence in a mountaineering shoe is gentle weight for quick motion throughout lengthy summer time adventures, the Cascadias are a winner.

Sturdiness

The Cascadias have numerous options that give them added sturdiness. Skinny TPU overlays reinforce vital areas just like the toe, sides, and heel to offer further safety in opposition to typical path obstacles like dust, roots, and bramble. The rubber tread extends over a portion of the toe for further resistance in opposition to scuffs and impacts from rocky terrain, and the laces are textured, flat, and long-lasting. We additionally just like the Velcro gaiter attachment on the heel (gaiters bought individually) to assist maintain particles out of the shoe and decrease abrasion on the mesh uppers whereas mountaineering.

However, there’s no method round it: the Cascadia 17s are usually not our first decide for sturdiness. They’re at the start path runners, so that they’re meant to be gentle, quick, and ethereal and aren’t corresponding to burly mountaineering footwear with leather-based uppers, thick outsoles, and protecting options. The mesh uppers are liable to blowing out across the toe space after roughly 400 miles of use – however that quantity is way decrease if you happen to’re mountaineering technical terrain. Additionally, the tread on these footwear doesn’t final particularly lengthy, with the lugs carrying down inside 300 miles, diminishing their grip, and the comfortable heel cuff wears down shortly with common on/off.

Climate Resistance

Considered one of our favourite issues in regards to the Cascadia 17s is that they dry shortly and supply stellar air flow. Their woven mesh uppers are wonderful at dumping warmth and expelling moisture, so that they’re superb for mountaineering and working on scorching days with sweaty toes. They’re additionally a fantastic selection for hikes with a number of water crossings since they dry many of the method inside solely 30-40 minutes after being totally submerged in water – though they are going to take longer to dry in climates with excessive humidity and decrease elevation. And, the gaiter attachment on the heel is a sensible characteristic to maintain particles, rocks, and water out of your footwear.

Nonetheless, the Cascadia 17s are usually not weather-resistant and tackle water shortly as a result of their mesh uppers. You’ll need to look elsewhere if you happen to’re mountaineering in shoulder seasons or colder circumstances the place your toes may get chilly and moist simply. Their lack of insulation and waterproofing means they received’t maintain toes heat in colder climate, so that you’ll need to maintain these completely for summer time adventures.

Ought to You Purchase the Brooks Cascadia 17?

The Brooks Cascadia 17s are soft, secure, and responsive footwear good for path runners, day hikers, and long-distance backpackers. In the event you’re searching for strong all-around footwear that’s light-weight, versatile, and breathable to knock out in depth mileage on established trails, the Cascadias are for you. With over 6,000 miles logged by our group on trails throughout the nation, these footwear have confirmed their consolation, performance, and dependability for years. They provide a steadiness of durability and agility, making them good for nearly any journey on a path, from deserts to forests and past. 

Nonetheless, the Cascadia 17s aren’t probably the most sturdy footwear, so we don’t advocate them if you happen to’re heading off-trail or into particularly rugged terrain. Whereas they’re extremely gentle and breathable, the higher mesh is prone to break and doesn’t maintain up properly via bushwhacks, scree, and rocky trails in comparison with mountaineering footwear with sturdy leather-based uppers or strengthened toes and heels. We additionally discover they’ve much less floor really feel than different path runners, which is likely to be a problem for navigating obstacles. However if you happen to’re searching for a dependable, versatile, and well-rounded path shoe for working and mountaineering, the Cascadia 17s will maintain your toes completely happy.

What Different Climbing Sneakers Ought to You Contemplate?

Topo Athletic Ultraventure 3:  The Topo Athletic Ultraventure 3 are simply as versatile and cozy because the Cascadias, with a equally ethereal and light-weight design because of gentle, breathable mesh uppers. Nonetheless, the Ultraventure 3s have a roomier toe field for pure foot flexion and a lacing system situated larger on the foot for a extra custom-made match.

HOKA Speedgoat 5: In the event you just like the soft soles, springy really feel, and secure experience of the Cascadia 17s, the Speedgoat 5s take these options to the following degree. Just like the Cascadias, the Speedgoats provide unmatched consolation and agility however have a decrease heel-to-toe drop with probably the most foam cushioning of any path runner we’ve examined.

Saucony Peregrine 14: The Peregrines are a really shut competitor to the Cascadias with their equally light-weight building, breathable uppers, and superior versatility on path. Nonetheless, the Peregrines have a extra aggressive lug sample that provides higher traction and fewer foam via the midsole for higher floor really feel.