After canceling plans for an on-property Brightline high-speed rail station two years in the past, Walt Disney World is now open to a SunRail prepare station on-site at Disney Springs. This publish shares particulars concerning the growth and what’s modified, how a lot it’ll price, plus commentary together with why this was by no means meant to be the alternative for Disney’s Magical Specific.
Walt Disney World shared in an announcement to Orlando Enterprise Journal that they’d be open to debate a SunRail station at Disney Springs. The shared Sunshine Hall between Miami-based Brightline and the Central Florida commuter rail system would come with stops at Orlando Worldwide Airport, Orange County Conference Middle and South Worldwide Drive.
“We have now lengthy been open to discussions across the proposed SunRail enlargement to Disney Springs and have been engaged with state and neighborhood leaders on the subject,” a Walt Disney World spokesperson wrote in an announcement. “This isn’t to be confused with the settlement we beforehand had for a Brightline station that Brightline determined to not pursue.”
Walt Disney World has been absent from Sunshine Hall discussions for the previous two years, together with in the course of the latest dispute between Governor DeSantis and Disney over management of the previous Reedy Creek Enchancment District and present Central Florida Tourism Oversight District.
Regardless of this, Brightline has remained involved in a station at Disney. The Sunshine Hall examine unveiled Thursday depicts riders and prices related to a cease at Disney Springs, in keeping with the Orlando Sentinel.
“Previously, Disney has expressed to the [Florida’s Department of Transportation’s Central Florida district] that they’re very involved in increasing SunRail to Disney,” stated John Tyler, secretary of the division. “We have now continued to deal with getting a connection to that time. It is smart from a transportation standpoint and now we have no cause to consider we shouldn’t be pursuing that.”
The Florida Division of Transportation launched that assertion as a part of a presentation in late April 2024 that included price and ridership estimates on the hall. Increasing SunRail to Orlando’s airport and the area’s tourism hall would enhance ridership no less than sixfold within the first 12 months of operation however come at an eye-popping price of no less than $4 billion. The presentation included the potential for a Disney Springs station, which might price $173 million to $247 million to construct.
Tyler stated the division’s yearlong examine discovered that linking SunRail to airport and tourism stops would enhance ridership from the present 1 million yearly to six million yearly–and that’s more likely to be an underestimate. He additionally pointed to an estimate that the hyperlink would attain an estimated 9.4 million riders by 2040, and indicated the examine outcomes have been extraordinarily optimistic.
The issue can be funding. These ~$4 billion in prices must come from the taxpayers, with a mixture of native, state and federal funding, in addition to vital non-public contributions. That’s the most important roadblock for the Sunshine Hall–Orange County Mayor Jerry Demings could be very bullish on the challenge and helps a gross sales tax hike to fund the challenge, however different mayors and metropolis commissioners on SunRail’s board are extra combined.
With no devoted supply of funding, it’ll be tough to get the Sunshine Hall performed. The identical was additionally true of Brightline to start with, and the challenge was seen as unbelievable after loads of failed rail initiatives previously couple of a long time. Not solely is Brightline now operational, however the group is already engaged on one other line from Las Vegas to Los Angeles. I’d’ve guess towards this again in ~2019, however not anymore.
For many who are unfamiliar with this entire saga, the Sunshine Hall and the Brightline and Sunrail plans, we’ll shortly convey you up to the mark. A number of years in the past, Brightline signed signed a letter of intent with Walt Disney World. Brightline had secured rights to problem $1.75 billion in tax-free bonds, and the 170-mile Central Florida hall had 35 miles of latest prepare right-of-way constructed alongside the Beachline Expressway. It was an formidable plan, however there have been a whole lot of formidable prepare plans for Central Florida that haven’t gone wherever.
Issues obtained extra actual in November 2020, when Walt Disney World revealed that the corporate would assist considerably broaden its transportation community by including a Brightline prepare station at Disney Springs. The events issued a joint announcement revealing that Brightline and Disney formalized plans and entered into an settlement on station building.
Nevertheless, that settlement was scrapped again in June 2022, when Walt Disney World revealed that the corporate’s plans for an on-property station to hook up with the multibillion-dollar Brightline challenge are not any extra. This occurred after the proposed route for Brightline modified from alongside State Street 417 to go nearer to Worldwide Drive, with the brand new route referred to as the Sunshine Hall.
“As many people who find themselves concerned on this challenge are conscious, the brand new route configuration doesn’t assist a Disney Springs station and consequently, we don’t anticipate being a part of this challenge,” stated Walt Disney World spokesperson Avery Maehrer on the time. That wasn’t the top of it, although.
Shortly thereafter, Brightline launched an announcement that though the unique plan referred to as for a single station at Disney Springs, a broad vary of stakeholders got here up with another answer–referred to as the Sunshine Hall–that may service extra of the vacationer hall.
Representatives of I-Drive companies, Common Orlando, Orange County Conference Middle and even the Metropolis of Orlando all pushed for the Sunshine Hall route with a purpose to service many extra theme parks, inns, and associated companies in want of rail transportation to the airport. Common even pledged land and financial assist to make the Sunshine Hall a actuality.
The Sunshine Hall would function two new stations and integrates Brightline’s intercity service with SunRail. Along with the Orlando Worldwide Airport, one new station can be situated close to Common’s Epic Universe and Orange County Conference Middle. Brightline revealed that there may be another station positioned close to the unique Disney Springs web site, albeit not on land owned by Disney as a part of the Sunshine Hall plan.
Principally, it grew to become a traditional case of Walt Disney World vs. Common Orlando, with the latter mounting an effort to alter Brightline’s most well-liked route and garnering assist from different companies and the town itself. Common additionally pledged cash and land for the challenge, which actually didn’t damage their trigger.
Common was profitable, however in so doing, the corporate dramatically delayed the challenge–as a result of it as soon as extra needed to undergo layers of approval–and triggered Walt Disney World to again out. It was at all times going to be Common or Disney profitable, so it was primarily a foregone conclusion that Disney would take its ball and go residence if its most well-liked route didn’t win out.
Turning to commentary, nothing that’s occurred previous to 2024 has been notably stunning. It’s no less than a little bit shocking that Walt Disney World is reentering the foray, and appears amenable to creating an on-site SunRail station occur.
The very first thing that at all times comes up with dialogue of Brightline is Disney’s Magical Specific. So we’ll begin with the reminder that this rail was by no means billed as a alternative for DME. Some followers proceed to say that Brightline is the “cause” Disney’s Magical Specific ended, however that’s demonstrably false.
If the prepare have been changing the bus, it stands to cause that Disney’s Magical Specific wouldn’t have ended 5+ years earlier than the proposed/cancelled/proposed once more station at Walt Disney World really went into service. There have been additionally a spread of sensible the reason why Brightline was by no means meant as a DME alternative, from prepare frequency to transfers from Disney Springs to inns.
The profit to companies within the vacationer hall is connecting Orlando to Florida’s Gold Coast. Visitors from South Florida are a rising demographic for Disney, and rail would facilitate simpler weekend getaways for them. It could even be helpful for high-spending convention-goers to journey inside the state. These are the 2 huge advantages of this from the angle of the theme parks. It was by no means about changing an airport shuttle bus. There have been–and are–higher methods to perform that.
As inefficient as it’s, Mears Join Pushed by Sunshine is in all probability simpler and sooner than this rail can be for getting from MCO to a selected lodge at Walt Disney World. With that stated, if the Disney Springs cease have been a correct prepare station full with baggage lockers, I might see taking the prepare in and hitting the bottom operating with arrival day at Disney Springs–then heading to our lodge. Particularly if we arrived earlier than our room was prepared.
As for Walt Disney World rethinking its resolution about an on-site station, I believe there are a few potential explanations for this. The primary is that Walt Disney World had hoped that backing out of the challenge in 2022 would’ve killed it, or no less than made it much less more likely to succeed.
That was their play on the time. It was an unsurprising one as a result of Walt Disney World has at all times acted in its pursuits to protect the “Disney Bubble” and never make it simpler for vacationers to bounce freely between on-site and off-site points of interest.
It’s potential that now that Disney sees the Sunshine Hall persevering with ahead, they’d fairly be a part of it than neglected utterly. That’s one potential rationalization, however the line remains to be removed from a certain factor. Walt Disney World’s involvement may be seen as a hedge, however it additionally may be seen as growing the probability of success for the road.
The important thing distinction between mid-2022 and 2024 is top-level management, with Bob Iger changing Bob Chapek as CEO. (WDW President Jeff Vahle and Parks Chairman Josh D’Amaro have been in place then and now.) This looks as if a call that may be made on the CEO stage, so it’s potential that Iger is in favor of this and Chapek was not. The latter might positively be accused of being shortsighted, and I’d argue that’s what the 2022 resolution was.
One other risk is that the corporate’s calculus has modified. Walt Disney World has already acknowledged that the Disney Bubble has been punctured because of the rise of rideshare coupled with extra rental vehicles and plentiful transportation round Central Florida.
That’s exactly why they ended Disney’s Magical Specific. However that call was made earlier than the one to again out of the Disney Springs station in 2022. They already knew it was going to be tougher to take care of the captive on-site viewers going ahead.
A closing risk is that, with Epic Universe opening in 2025, Walt Disney World now sees the free move of visitors as a two-way avenue. Not will they be “dropping” visitors for a day or two at Common by making it simpler to enterprise off-site. Going ahead, extra visitors may also keep on-site at Common Orlando and need to make day journeys to Disney. Consider this as a spin on the “rising tide lifts all ships” line of pondering.
My finest guess is that it’s some mixture of the above. Having an built-in station on-site at Disney Springs is the sensible transfer, and one which performs the lengthy sport. It acknowledges that Mario and Harry Potter and dragons are going to attract extra vacationers to Central Florida, and people individuals may also have an curiosity in Encanto, Indiana Jones, no matter is Past Massive Thunder, and mice.
Disney enjoying ball is clearly the guest-friendly transfer, however I believe it’s one which’s additionally good for the long-term way forward for Walt Disney World. And whereas we don’t play this sport usually, it’s what Walt would’ve wished (he liked two issues: chili and trains). Right here’s hoping that it really occurs!
Planning a Walt Disney World journey? Find out about inns on our Walt Disney World Accommodations Critiques web page. For the place to eat, learn our Walt Disney World Restaurant Critiques. To economize on tickets or decide which sort to purchase, learn our Suggestions for Saving Cash on Walt Disney World Tickets publish. Our What to Pack for Disney Journeys publish takes a novel have a look at intelligent gadgets to take. For what to do and when to do it, our Walt Disney World Experience Guides will assist. For complete recommendation, the perfect place to begin is our Walt Disney World Journey Planning Information for the whole lot you should know!
YOUR THOUGHTS
What do you concentrate on Walt Disney World being “open” to having an on-property rail station? Optimistic that Disney will view this as a superb factor within the long-term and construct a station at Disney Springs? Do you agree or disagree with our evaluation? Any questions we might help you reply? Listening to your suggestions—even once you disagree with us—is each attention-grabbing to us and useful to different readers, so please share your ideas beneath within the feedback!
